2008年7月19日 星期六

自由談 八月二十三號 (2008 )主題:「左派 右派」;「獨立出版」;「翻譯學」

這個會因引言人另外有要事而取消 特此通知

如果造成不便 請原諒


漢清,我在高雄的伙伴告訴我,23日要我南下主持高雄社區大學和高雄市原住民族部落大學的聯合課程博覽會,由於我是理事長,必須去宣揚我們的理念,並給工作人員和老師們打氣,所以原訂的左派右派的談話會,不得不改期。非常抱歉,我知道你已把信息廣發出去,你們是否還是如期舉行,如有必要,我們擇期再加一場?抱歉!抱歉!


----

新生南路 自由談

主題:「左派 右派」;「獨立出版」;「翻譯學」

時間:八月二十三號 (2008),14:00-16:00

地點:台北市新生南路三段88號2樓: TEL. 23650127

與談人:【引言人】陳巨擘先生(政治大學出版社)

報名:請發EMAIL至HCSIMONL@GMAIL.COM

說明:

主要因緣是7月12日有朋友訪問這兒,多少會被窗外的園林景觀吸引。我之前正與一位對於趙元任等先進的專家聊天。我們說,說不定可以來談談。後來,陳巨擘先生說,他受邀講「你是左派還是右派?──教師會幹部的意識型態」*,可以來引言。


陳巨擘:「左派或右派是種生活態度、處事原則,在實踐上,很難有純左派或是純右派,但每個人大概都會有個自己所認同的生活態度或處事原則。再以Said的話來說,沒有純粹的 private intellectual,也沒有純粹的 public intellectual。」


我們認為,他在出版界的翻譯經驗豐富,如果有人對出版的世界有興趣,他也可以談談呢。他說,我們共同的朋友有許多高手,下次可以請東海大學的羅時瑋先生談『華嚴經與日本建築』呢…..

更多細節請參考

http://hclectures.blogspot.com/

*

附上「你是左派還是右派」的講綱。
你是左派還是右派? ──教師會幹部的意識型態
1. 我是左派或右派關你什麼事?
a. 教育可以是中立的嗎?
b. 教育在台灣百年來的發展實況
c. 意識型態在教育上的作用:潛在課程
i) 阿圖塞(Louis Althusser)-- 政治、哲學
ii) 波勒和金蒂斯(Bowles & Gintis)-- 經濟
iii) 艾普爾(Michael Apple)-- 社會

2. 教育思潮中左右派之戰爭 a. 資本主義 vs. 社會主義 b. 保守主義 vs. 進步主義 c. 新自由主義 vs. 批判理論

3. 教師做為教學工具 vs. 教師做為知識分子 a. 葛蘭西(Antonio Gramsci) b. 弗雷勒(Paulo Freire) c. 薩伊德(Edward Said) d. 吉魯(Henry Giroux)

4. 結論:你/妳想當左派還是右派?
a. 教育的目的
b. 當今台灣左派教育工作者所面臨的挑戰
c. 如何empowering education





聚會時程:


東海戴明學者講座【2008特邀威廉‧謝爾肯巴赫先生(Mr. William W. Scherkenbach.)擔任三場演講-討論。】

I 開幕大戲【Lecture One: Dr. Deming's System of Profound Knowledge and Its Applications. 10月16日 (四)】 1500-1700,中華民國品質學會【台北羅斯福路】

II. 壓軸戲【Lecture two: Statistical Thinking and Psychology and Actions. 10月17日 ,10/17(五) 16:10-06:00 台中東海大學工業工程】

III 大軸子【Lecture Three: Systems Thinking and Knowledge.. 10月18日(六) 上午10:00-12:00 台中東海大學推廣部】





2008年7月11日 星期五

How the New Quality Movement Is Transforming Medicine.

W. Edwards Deming (1900-93)生前就這樣說過

“The best way for a student to learn a skill is to go to work in some good company (or hospital), under masters, and get paid while he learns.” W. Edwards Deming, Out of the Crisis




Re: QRDC開會7/11記錄
我常說 我可以寫出不在會議記錄中的許多事情
上次會議中 我強力建議品質學會成立healthcare 委員會
我說日本科技連盟 JUSE多年前就出版過"醫療品質手冊"
我說..... 我說.....

現在 用紐約時報的一篇書評代替"我說"

唯一要補充的是 提議人似乎也可以當跑腿...

謝謝王主委

Books

Crusaders for Quality, a Health-Care Intangible


By ABIGAIL ZUGER, M.D
Published: July 29, 2008

Correction Appended

There are more than 800,000 doctors in this country, more than two million nurses and several million other health care workers. Until recently no one really knew what any of them were up to. Hospital walls bulged with frenetic activity, but all the public saw were the happy successes and the occasional tragic complications.

Skip to next paragraph
Clare Mallison

The Best Practice
How the New Quality Movement Is Transforming Medicine.
By Charles Kenney. PublicAffairs. 315 Pages. $26.95

RSS Feed

Those days are pretty much over. From what has been called a perfect storm of disgruntled patients, legislators and medical professionals, the quality movement in health care has been born.

Thanks to its efforts, those hospital walls are slowly becoming transparent. Revealed is a world of tangled routines, many obsolescent, many downright stupid, that no one had carefully examined. The reformers are out to streamline the routines, retrain the workers and keep them permanently on display — an ant farm behind clear glass — to make sure things never get out of control again.

Their early work was invisible to the public, but even that is changing. Take, for example, the latest benchmark in transparency: on a Wednesday late last May, newspaper readers across the country could compare how local hospitals performed on two measurements of the quality of care, not by slogging through a news article but by scanning a large government-sponsored advertisement complete with graphs and a Web address (www.hospitalcompare.hhs.gov) for more details.

That is just the first installment of such data on display. Soon both hospitals and individual practitioners will be publicizing their own report cards. Insurers will be paying them for good grades, penalizing them for bad. Incentives to minimize errors, complications and inefficiency will mount. Health care will become perfectly safe, perfectly smooth, perfectly perfect.

How did this messianic movement arise and take root, and who are its prophets? These are the questions Charles Kenney valiantly tries to answer in what is the first large-scale history of the quality movement.

Mr. Kenney, a former Boston Globe reporter and editor who is a consultant for a Massachusetts health insurance company, has set himself a giant assignment. While the book is not a success — an uncritical paean to his subjects, it reads like a corporate annual report — he provides a reasonably complete and up-to-date picture of the ambition and complexity of the enterprise.

Part of the problem is that he is trying to describe a target in motion, with roots almost as tangled as the chaos it seeks to eradicate. Poor-quality health care takes a variety of forms, each attracting a different set of crusaders.

Some have taken on the big blunders — errors of misdosed medication and operations on the wrong leg. Some have tackled "complications," like catheter infections, that were once thought to be inevitable risks of hospitalization and now seem entirely preventable.

Some have focused on the smaller inefficiencies — little details with costly consequences, like medical records that disappear just when they are most needed and laboratory results that vanish into giant black holes.

Some aim to rearrange the physician-heavy hospital hierarchy so that all health care workers, and even family members, have the opportunity to call the shots in a patient's care.

Still others focus on getting sick people correctly cared for: tight blood-sugar control for diabetics, regular Pap smears for women, flu shots for all.

Government and industry have been sources of inspiration for these goals. Experts from NASA to Toyota have tutored health quality gurus in the basics, like needing to prevent errors rather than punish them and respecting the right of any worker to stop the assembly line when a mistake threatens.

Mr. Kenney is scornfully dismissive of unnamed physician naysayers who point out that "human beings are not cars" and shy away from health quality control. It is these doctors' "crust of hubris," he argues, that prevents them from seeing the merits of new algorithms. Indeed, it is hard to imagine how any sane person could fail to leap on the quality bandwagon as presented here; it is all so self-evidently fabulous.

But readers should be aware that Mr. Kenney's story ignores a wide array of questions that have some thoughtful members of the health care world a little troubled by the quality evangelism.

What does quality care mean, for instance, in cases of hopeless illness? When the outcome of care will not be good, how should good care be redefined? Suppose patients sabotage their own care, as so many unwittingly do. Who takes the blame?

And most important, what does it mean when science impudently undercuts accepted quality benchmarks? Only this past spring, for instance, two giant trials suggested that for some diabetics, tight blood-sugar control did nothing to safeguard them against some feared complications of diabetes and might actually endanger them.

Quality is a clear goal in product development, but in health it is still a shimmering intangible. All credit to the quality mavens; they are certainly fighting the good fight, and most of them deserve every laudatory adjective in Mr. Kenney's thesaurus.

But fortunately for us all, most of them are smart enough to realize that human beings are not cars.

This article has been revised to reflect the following correction:

Correction: July 30, 2008
The Books column on Tuesday, about "The Best Practice," by Charles Kenney, misstated the name of the publisher. It is PublicAffairs, not Public Affairs Books.